The moment an interviewer asks, “Tell me about a time you dealt with a difficult colleague,” your heart might sink a little. It feels like a trap, a chance to complain or sound unprofessional. But it’s not—it’s an opportunity to show your professionalism and problem-solving skills.

Why Interviewers Ask This Question

Interviewers ask this question to assess several key competencies without you even realizing it. They want to see how you handle conflict, your emotional intelligence, and your ability to maintain a professional demeanor under pressure. Your answer reveals your communication style, your problem-solving approach, and whether you’re a team player or someone who blames others.

The Foolproof Framework: The STAR Method

The best way to answer this or any behavioral question is with the STAR method. This simple framework allows you to tell a concise, compelling story that highlights your skills and leads to a positive resolution.

• S – Situation: Set the scene.
• T – Task: Describe your role and the specific goal.
• A – Action: Detail the steps you took to address the problem.
• R – Result: Explain the positive outcome.

Breaking Down the STAR Method for this Question

S – Situation: Set the Scene (No Blame Game)

Start with a brief, objective description of the situation. Avoid using emotionally charged language or speaking negatively about your colleague. The focus should be on the professional challenge, not the person.

• Example: “In my previous role as a project coordinator, our team was working on a high-stakes client presentation, and there was a communication breakdown that was delaying our progress.”

T – Task: What Was Your Role?

Clearly state your responsibility and the goal that was at risk due to the situation. This shows the interviewer you are a proactive and responsible team member.

• Example: “My task was to ensure all team members’ contributions were integrated smoothly and that we hit our deadline for the final report.”

A – Action: What Did YOU Do? (Focus on Your Proactivity)

This is the most critical part. Detail the specific, professional, and diplomatic actions you took. Did you schedule a one-on-one meeting? Did you suggest a new communication tool? The key is to show you took initiative to find a solution.

• Example: “I initiated a private conversation with the colleague to understand their perspective. I listened to their concerns about workload and proposed we use a shared project management tool to track our progress, ensuring clear visibility for everyone.”

R – Result: The Positive Outcome

End your story on a positive note. Describe the resolution and the impact of your actions. Did the project succeed? Was the relationship improved? Did you learn a valuable lesson?

• Example: “The new system drastically improved our communication. We not only met our deadline but delivered the presentation with great success, and my working relationship with that colleague improved significantly. I learned the importance of proactive communication to prevent misunderstandings.”

Example Answers for Different Roles

Example 1: The Project Manager

Situation: “In a previous role, I was managing a marketing campaign where a senior designer was consistently missing deadlines, which put the entire project timeline at risk.”
Task: “My task was to ensure the campaign launched on time while maintaining team morale and creative quality.”
Action: “I scheduled a one-on-one meeting with the designer to address the issue directly. Instead of focusing on the missed deadlines, I asked what challenges they were facing. It turned out they were overloaded with other projects. I collaborated with them to re-prioritize their workload and found another team member who could assist with a few smaller tasks to ease their burden.”
Result: “This open dialogue not only resolved the immediate bottleneck, but it also prevented a project delay. The designer appreciated my proactive approach, and we were able to deliver a high-quality campaign on schedule. It taught me the value of understanding the ‘why’ behind a team member’s struggles.”

Example 2: The Software Engineer

Situation: “In a previous engineering team, I worked with a colleague who had a different coding style, which led to frequent conflicts during code reviews and slowed down our development cycle.”
Task: “My task was to collaborate effectively to deliver our sprint goals on time.”
Action: “I recognized that the issue was a lack of a standardized process. I took the initiative to propose and lead a brief session where we could establish clear coding standards and review protocols. We collaboratively created a small style guide that we all agreed upon and committed to following.”
Result: “This effort resulted in a dramatic reduction in our code review time and improved the overall quality of our codebase. We were able to accelerate our sprint velocity, and the team developed a more respectful and productive way of working together. This experience reinforced my belief in the importance of establishing clear team-wide protocols.”

---